Skip to content
The Crossbencher

Today’s News31 July 2026 at 19:30

Burnham wants mayors to keep income tax - the centre rarely lets go

The Crossbencher Newsdesk

Share on XWhatsAppFacebookEmail

The Crossbencher

Andy Burnham has called for metro mayors to receive a share of income tax raised in their regions, arguing the money should be used to "empower" local areas rather than fund short-term tax cuts. The proposal has drawn criticism in Whitehall, the BBC reports, while the Guardian's editorial backs his push to "unbundle" England's centralised state.

The Mayor of Greater Manchester has also appointed Jack Patterson, a Grammy-winning member of Clean Bandit, as a top economic adviser - a move that caused a stir in the Treasury, according to the Daily Mail. The Sun notes concerns inside Whitehall about Burnham's time away from No10, while Louise Haigh has urged the government to govern boldly. The Express argues Burnham should use any new powers to scrap net zero policies, calling them "lunatic".

The bench notes: devolution proposals arrive in waves, usually when the centre is under pressure. Income tax sharing has been floated before - the Scotland Act 2016 gave Holyrood control over rates and bands, though collection remained reserved. The difference is consent: Scotland voted for a parliament. English regions have not voted for metro mayors to set their income tax, and Whitehall has historically treated fiscal devolution as a one-way valve - powers granted are rarely clawed back, even when the experiment disappoints.

What to watch: whether the Treasury publishes costings for the proposal, and whether any other metro mayor backs it publicly. If they stay silent, that tells you something about the appetite beyond Manchester.

Sources and receipts (9) +
  • as captured - The Mirror: Andy Burnham says extra cash for mayors should be used to 'empower' regions - not for short term tax cuts source · ba5d8764…
  • as captured - The Sun: Andy Burnham’s time away from No10 sparks concern inside Whitehall as Louise Haigh urges bold governing source · 7b34edc4…
  • as captured - Daily Express: Andy Burnham must take this action to stop Ceuta migrant crisis reaching Britain source · 658cf494…
  • as captured - The Mirror: Andy Burnham appoints Grammy-winning Clean Bandit star as top economic adviser source · 2b86718a…
  • as captured - The Guardian: The Guardian view on England’s centralised state: Andy Burnham must unbundle it | Editorial source · 8299a427…
  • as captured - BBC News: Burnham faces criticism over plans for mayors to get share of income tax source · 4e38eb8e…
  • as captured - Daily Express: With climate loon Ed Miliband gone, Andy Burnham must scrap 'lunatic' net zero policies source · 8cae8604…
  • as captured - Daily Mail: Andy Burnham appoints former pop band star and heartthrob to be his top economic adviser after causing a stir in the Treasury source · 28ea6580…
  • The Scotland Act 2016 gave Holyrood control over income tax rates and bands.: Scotland Act 2016 source · 36ac0c8d…

What do you think?

Sign in — it's free to add your take, reply, and vote on others.

No takes yet. Be the first to make the argument.

← All of today’s news

The daily edition

The day, with the receipts attached.

One email each morning: today’s quiz, the Bench question, the argument and what broke - every figure with its source. Free, and it saves your streak. Stop it any time from one link at the bottom of it.

No password, no confirmation hoop - the stop link is in every issue. Just want the weekly editorial? →