When a pattern is ugly and everywhere, the mind goes looking for the hand behind it. Usually there's no hand. It's the less comforting thought and the more useful one.
Crossbencher · 18 July 2026
Sometimes there really is a hand. Cartels fix prices. Lobbies write the clauses that suit them. Movements organise, plan, and get their way. A theory of public life that waves all of that away as coincidence is naive, and worse, disarmed. Coordination is real. Where it happens, name it and fight it.
But most coordinated-looking outcomes aren't coordinated. They are what you get when a lot of people react, separately and sensibly, to the same incentive. The results line up. They look designed. Nobody designed them. This is the oldest idea in social science and the least intuitive one. Hayek used it to explain how a market sets a price no committee could ever calculate. Schelling used it to show how a city segregates when not one resident wants it to - each person makes a small, tolerant choice, and the choices add up to a wall.
Members only
Every writer, every column
The last 30 days of the argument are free for everyone, always. The archive beyond that is a Member thing - it is part of what keeps the whole record free.
One email a day: today’s quiz, the Bench question, the argument and what broke - every figure with its source. Free, and it saves your streak. Stop it any time from one link at the bottom of it.